For a prospective (or existing) Haafith ( Protector/Preserver حافظ or the more technical term Haamil: Carrier حامل) there are 3 areas to consider as part of their learning.
1) Memorising the Qur’aan – properly. There are different levels of memorisation. Some are proud of knowing the page number, how many ayaat there are, the ayah number and so on. Bottom line is that you don’t need to. If it comes with practice and study then الحمد لله but personally I wouldn’t consider it that important – especially initially, and it certainly isn’t the goal of hifth. It is good for bragging though… but maybe I’m jealous.
Main thing is to be aware of the ayaat that are similar (mutashaabihaat) in the Qur’aan. This can be achieved by revising/reciting lots (which should be normal anyway) so that you realise that there are similar ayaat because it is during your revision/reciting that you get muddled/mix ayaat up and realise that there are areas which need to be tackled slightly differently. Some students utilise books on the mutashaabihaat during their hifth, others wait until after finishing, others never do, and some use them when they realise they are getting confused. All the books do is give you some sort of mental anchor by which you can place the ayah in its proper place. The best anchor is the one you form yourself and that can be done by listing the ayaat that you mix and then seeing what the differences are between them, which ayaat are before and after, and how the meaning or grammar differs.
2a) Reading with Tajweed – this involves knowing where letters are pronounced from, the qualities they have, how the order of letters affects them (rules) and where to start and stop reading. It also involves being able to articulate the letters to form words to a standard which is recognised as being accomplished and deserving of an ijaazah. This is a base level. From here on you find differences in knowledge, ability and excellence (itqaan). Not every person with an ijaazah is going to be excellent. They should all be highly competent but not necessarily excellent. By this I mean that there will be a difference in how perfectly the letters are pronounced and the clarity of reading. Other qualities such as a nice voice, emotion and melody have nothing to do with an ijaazah and it is the ignorant masses who value these over perfection of Tajweed.
It’s like anything else. You complete a mechanic’s qualification but it doesn’t automatically make you the best mechanic. It means that you have reached a level of competency which deserves that particular certification. This leads to an important point that even after getting an ijaazah there is still potential for increase in expertise and application. (There is also room for solidifying one’s memorisation although solid memorisation of the Qur’aan is a pre-requisite for an ijaazah.)
Hifth of a portion of the Qur’aan is a requirement for every Muslim as it is necessary for them to pray properly. As a result it is necessary to learn Tajweed as best as one can.
It is important to remember that there is a clear difference between knowledge and application of Tajweed and that of Qiraa’aat. They are different sciences, which like many of the Islamic sciences, are related. Simply put, Tajweed is concerned with pronouncing letters properly and in accordance with the Arabic norm at the time of revelation. The vast majority of Tajweed is Arabic language based, what the Qur’aan has come with that is different in particular is the lengthening of sounds such as ghunnah and madd. It is also vital to know how to stop and start reading.
Qiraa’aat is concerned with allowed differences in word formation (as per Arab usage) and dialectical variations. It builds on Tajweed although it is a separate science. Tajweed takes priority. These are simple definitions and more comprehensive ones are available in Tajweed and Uloom ul Qur’aan books.
There are plenty of people who have mastered the 10 Qiraa’aat (Lesser and/or Greater) but haven’t mastered Tajweed. There are a variety of mistakes present in their reading, some are major mistakes, some are minor. Yet these people have received an ijaazah and this highlights a problem. Many shuyookh are not particularly strict or diligent when it comes to certifying students. I have experienced this myself and have prayed behind somebody who has major mistakes in their reading of Surah Al Faatihah but yet is mujaaz. The sad thing is that if they were to be corrected by someone who isn’t mujaaz they don’t accept the advice, as if they are hiding behind their ijaazah and using it as a shield to protect their ego, may Allah save us. I genuinely think some are deaf though.
We do need to appreciate that perhaps when the student received the ijaazah their reading was at the required level and free from major mistakes and for whatever reasons it has deteriorated to the point which has just been heard. However if this is the case and the student has recently achieved an ijaazah then this is problematic as it indicates a lack of trustworthiness on behalf of the teacher and ignorance on behalf of the student. This highlights the importance of selecting teachers who are competent and honest.
I would like to add a side point here that is a practice from the time of the Prophet صلى الله عليه و سلَم and the Companions رضي الله عنهم . Teaching is focused on advanced students who take priority and then in turn teach the less advanced/beginning students. It is similar to teachers at University level who do not teach primary school children, the students they teach will have prior studying and understanding. The Companions رضي الله عنهم also followed this structure, notably Abdullah bin Masood and Abu Dardaa’ (who are from the 8 Companions that all the riwaayaat of the Qur’aan trace their chain of transmissions back to as they took it directly from the Prophet صلى الله عليه و سلَم and are known to have memorised the Qur’aan completely during his lifetime and read it to him) by having students in groups of ten with an advanced student overseeing them. This ‘supervisor’ would refer back to his teacher as necessary. This structure puts less stress on a teacher and allows them to focus their energies on students who are close to fruition and becoming mujaaz and competent.
2b) Tajweed first, then riwaayaat. In order to study the Qiraa’aat you need to have memorised the Qur’aan in 1 base riwaayah at least. What this means is that you have learnt how to read the Qur’aan with Tajweed and know the ‘special’ words and their correct reading according to one chain of transmission e.g. Hafs (حفص). Memorising and understanding the poem, commonly known as الجزريّة, written by Imam Al Jazari رحمه الله will help immensely as it covers this and although not a prerequisite according to all Shuyookh worldwide, here at IESH you need to have memorised it and be able to explain it (you get questioned during your reading). In addition to this you need to have excellent memorisation otherwise you will find yourself getting very confused.
Knowledge of Arabic helps to not make silly mistakes such as reading a ت in place of a ي . The relation this has to the Qiraa’aat is that very often the differences (aside from that of أصول ) are as straightforward as a word like تعلمون being read as يعلمون . Weak memorisation in the base riwaayah means that words such as this will be read wrong (or at the very least in a state of doubt, reading correct at times and incorrect at times) and the reader may well console him/herself with the knowledge that it is still Qur’aan and an accepted way of reading. However what it means is that the reader is mixing riwaayaat, thereby rendering a reading that has no chain of transmission, and that is not allowed, the doors to ‘pic n mix’ are shut.
I personally don’t believe it worth learning how to read the Qur’aan (from the musshaf) in different riwaayaat purely on the basis that it acts as a distraction from memorising and also it doesn’t give you the level of knowledge that a Haafith would have.
3) Arabic – Some memorise the Qur’aan but have no grounding in the Arabic language and such people are prone to making mistakes in vowels and words so that they change the meaning without realising. These are major mistakes and one who has this as a feature of their recitation shouldn’t lead the people in prayer. Others have difficulty linking ayaat together, others are plagued by both. Overcoming this requires dedication, persistence and focused effort using appropriate means.
Understanding the meaning is crucial to a solid memorisation.
Having said that, even Arabs, who one would imagine understand the Qur’aan well, make terrible mistakes, I’ve prayed behind someone who put the disbelievers in Paradise for ever and went into ruku’.
This is enough to highlight the importance of understanding Arabic as it makes the memorisation process much easier due to eliminating careless mistakes and allowing for self-correction. In addition it allows internalisation of the Qur’aan, allowing the reader to avail of the opportunity to grow closer to الله سبحانه و تعالى and enjoy a conscious and intellectually stimulating experience with the Qur’aan which results in spiritual richness and nourishment (without this you may as well just count numbers or repeat the alphabet on autopilot). This also creates a deep and transforming awareness that the Qur’aan is preserved in the written and oral form.
In addition to this, understanding Arabic allows the student to access various books and resources that are available only in Arabic to accelerate their learning and overcome obstacles. For example books detailing with the mutashaabihaat, tafseer books of different types such as language, Hadith, Qur’aan etc…
There are other areas one can focus on, such as ‘Uloom ul Qur’aan and Tafseer, but in my limited studies so far, I have found the ones I’ve written about to be the most important in committing the Qur’aan to memory.